Should you sign in with Google, Apple or your email?
· 3 min read
Marta Kowalczyk writes about design and creative apps for Appcyclopedia, working on a MacBook Air, an iPhone 16 Pro and a Galaxy A55.
The short version
- Signing in with Google or Apple saves a password and is often more secure than a weak one. The cost is that your access depends on that account.
- Sign in with Apple can hide your real email address behind a private relay address. Google shares the address of the account you choose.
- Use your own email and a password manager for accounts you would need to recover on your own, such as anything financial.
- Whatever you choose, note it down. Forgetting which button you used is the most common way people lose an account.
The button that wins every time
Look at almost any sign-up screen and you will see the same arrangement: large buttons for Google and Apple at the top, and a smaller email option below, sometimes behind a link. As a designer, I understand why. The big buttons are one tap. The email route is a form, a password and a confirmation email. Fewer steps means more people finish.
So the layout is not neutral. It steers you towards the option that is easiest for the company to complete. That does not make it the wrong choice, but it is worth making on purpose.
What you trade for one tap
| Sign in with Google | Sign in with Apple | Email and password | |
|---|---|---|---|
| New password to remember | No | No | Yes |
| Site sees your real email | Yes | Optional, with Hide My Email | Yes |
| Security | Your Google account’s | Your Apple account’s | Only as good as your password |
| If you lose that account | Locked out of the site | Locked out of the site | Unaffected |
The middle column has a detail many people miss. Sign in with Apple can give the site a random address that forwards to your real one, so the site never learns your email. If you later want to stop hearing from it, you switch off the forwarding.
The dependency problem
Here is the part the button does not show. When you sign in with Google, your access to that site now depends on your Google account. If that account is closed, hacked or locked, every site you entered through it is locked too.
For a music app or a recipe site, that is a fair trade for convenience. For something you would need to get back into on your own, like a bank, insurance or a tax account, I would rather the account stood on its own, with its own email and password.
When I would choose each
- Google or Apple: everyday apps and sites, where convenience matters and losing access would be a nuisance, not a crisis.
- Apple with Hide My Email: sites you suspect will send marketing, or where you would rather not hand over your address.
- Email and a password manager: anything financial or official, and any account you might need to recover without a big company in the middle.
The habit that saves the most trouble
The most common sign-in problem is not security at all. It is forgetting which button you used. You come back a year later, try your email, and the site says it has never heard of you, because you signed up with Apple.
Write down how you signed in, or let a password manager record it. It takes seconds at sign-up and saves a frustrating search later.
A calmer way to look at that screen
The sign-up screen is designed so the fastest choice feels like the only one. Slow down for a second, ask how much this account matters, and pick the button that fits. For most apps, the big button is fine. For the few that really matter, the small link underneath is worth the extra minute.
Common questions
- Is signing in with Google safe?
- Generally yes. It uses your Google account’s security, including two-step verification, and the site never sees your Google password. The risk is that losing your Google account locks you out of the site too.
- What does Hide My Email do with Sign in with Apple?
- It gives the site a random relay address that forwards to your real email. You can stop the forwarding later without the site ever knowing your real address.
- Can I switch from Google sign-in to email later?
- It depends on the site. Many let you add a password or change the sign-in method in account settings; some do not, so choose carefully at the start.
Sources: Google Account Help, How Sign in with Google works Apple Support, How to use Hide My Email with Sign in with Apple
Share this post
Link copied
Was this post helpful?
What was missing?
Thanks, that helps us.